Table of Contents
Howie's column is powered by Lyric Kitchen · Bar | eMail Howie
Downtown Duluth isn’t dying. It’s just nursing the longest hangover in Minnesota.
Every few years someone declares the patient stable, and every few years the same tired symptoms return — empty storefronts, jittery pedestrians, consultants with clipboards measuring “vibrancy.”
Walk Superior Street on a Tuesday night and you’ll see what the metrics miss: a place that wants to wake up but keeps hitting snooze.
You can’t throw a rock downtown without hitting a “revitalization” plan. Each one promises “momentum,” “placemaking,” or some other word you can’t buy a cup of coffee with.
Meanwhile, half the lights are still dark, and the only steady traffic comes from Amazon vans and pigeons.
The optimism’s fine; the follow-through never shows. You can slap murals on plywood, but everyone still smells the rot underneath.
On a raw weekday morning, a barista unlocks her café while a city truck rattles past with a broken taillight. A man in three coats drifts by humming, and a squad car idles at the light.
The street looks calm enough, but you can feel the strain — a civic flinch that never quite relaxes. Downtown still runs, technically, but you can hear the grinding in the gears.
You can’t police despair. You can shuffle people from doorway to doorway, but that’s optics, not safety. The folks drifting between shelters and liquor stores aren’t statistics; they’re the part of downtown we keep editing out of the brochure.
Until there are treatment beds, sober housing, and somewhere better to go, the sidewalks will keep repeating the same story.
The people under the skywalks aren’t the villains; they’re the evidence. Addiction, mental illness, trauma — that’s what’s camped out down here.
Duluth dresses those problems up as “public safety,” because real solutions cost money and patience. What we call “revitalization” is usually avoidance with a logo. This town deserves better than marketing; it deserves mercy and a working plan.
The cruelest part is how good the place still looks if you squint. The lake flashes at the end of every block, the hillside glows at sunset. You can almost convince yourself it’s thriving until you notice your own echo on the sidewalk.
Geography never quit on Duluth; it just stopped being enough. You can book a band, build a patio, or stage a festival, but you can’t program your way past poverty or trauma.
Step into a bar on First Street and you’ll hear the same talk you’ve heard for twenty years — somebody moved their office to the mall, somebody’s kid bolted for the Cities, somebody’s cousin just lost another shop lease.
And still there’s laughter. Always is. Duluth drinks its pain like coffee — black, strong, and with a little pride.
Old-timers remember when Canal Park was the great hope. In the early ’80s, they said the boardwalk and brewpubs would spill life uphill into downtown. For a while, they did. Tour buses idled where coal cars once sat, and the city thought the tide had turned.
Then winter blew in off the lake, the crowd thinned, and the dream folded back into the binders. Every decade since has brought a new miracle cure — skywalks, tech hubs, creative corridors — and every one faded into the same gray season.
Still, Duluth’s geography mocks the pessimists. From Lake and Superior you can look east and swear it’s working again. A couple huddles in a bakery window, a busker tunes his guitar to the wind, the lake glints like a promise we keep forgetting to keep.
What keeps this town alive isn’t planning jargon — it’s the old iron-ore stubbornness that got us through the shipping busts, the smelter layoffs, and a thousand winters that would’ve finished softer places.
We’ve seen this movie. Every decade brings a fresh rendering with brighter buzzwords — “mixed-use,” “walkable,” “sustainable.” The drawings change, the sidewalks don’t.
Canal Park was going to save downtown. Then the Tech Village. Then the skywalk. If resilience paid taxes, Duluth would have a surplus. Instead, we live in civic déjà vu, rebuilding the same block for the fifth time.
And yet the city won’t die. Maybe that’s pride, maybe it’s habit. You see it in the barista opening shop at dawn, the owner painting over graffiti again, the nurse heading to a night shift through the sleet.
They keep showing up because that’s what Duluth does. It shows up, even when nobody’s watching.
Revival doesn’t come from renderings. It comes from repetition — from people who keep unlocking doors, sweeping sidewalks, turning lights on. From stubborn faith disguised as routine. That’s the real “activation.”
Downtown isn’t doomed; it’s just hard work no one wants to admit is hard. What it needs isn’t another cheerleader, it’s a clear-eyed witness — someone willing to tell the truth and still show up tomorrow.
Cities don’t die overnight; they erode and rebuild, one block, one conversation, one stubborn believer at a time.
Maybe that’s the hope worth holding — that Duluth keeps finding people too loyal, or too foolish, to give up. And if that sounds like criticism, it’s not.
It’s affection — the kind you earn by staying after everyone else leaves.
Howie Hanson writes from Duluth, where he’s been poking the city’s sacred cows since before half the current council learned to parallel park. He runs HowieHanson.com, a one-man newsroom powered by caffeine, sarcasm, and an allergy to PR spin. Part reporter, part historian, part irritant, he still believes in telling the truth—even when it makes the room uncomfortable.
